This tale may ruffle the feathers of vintage purists. Would you rout a 50’s Harmony archtop for a pickup?
As a rule, we and others in our profession have an unwritten standard that says you don’t do irreversable modifications to vintage guitars unless you absolutely have to. But there are times to interpret those rules strictly and times to be a bit more loose. Refinish your ’56 goldtop Les Paul in purple? Not here. Rout a ’61 Strat for EMG humbuckers? No chance. Install locking tuners on your pre-war Martin? Keep shopping.
Install a humbucker in an acoustic Harmony Monterey archtop that you got for a couple hundred bucks? Hmmm… maybe…
The owner of this old Harmony thought about it carefully and weighed the upside of keeping it original vs. turning it into a guitar he’d really like to play. Since its value will likely never be through the roof, he decided he’d rather hold onto it and convert it into a hollow body electric. He wisely chose Chicago Fret Works and a Lollar Imperial pickup for the job.
We created a custom routing template and carefully cut a hole to fit the new pickup. We also added a volume and tone control as well as a jack below the treble side F hole.
So did the owner of this guitar make a good decision? We think he did. He took a cool but not great old guitar that didn’t have a great deal of value and converted it into a unique custom guitar that he loves to play. If it was a 1940’s Gibson L-47 we would have argued against this work. But for this one, why not. And it sounds terrific.
We are proud to be the only authorized Chicago dealer of Lollar pickups. We feel they are among the best replacement pickups being made today. Who agrees and plays with them? Jeff Tweedy, Keith Richards, John Fogerty, Elliot Easton, Joe Perry, Johnny Marr and many, many more.
Could you do something like this for a mid-70’s Harmony Monterey TENOR guitar? How much would it run?
Sure. Only question is figuring out the right pickup. We’ll investigate and meet you back here!
great thanks!
I have a P-90 on the bridge of my ’46 Harmony archtop.
It rocks.
Ben,
It seems that the builders who make tenor guitars nowadays use a standard 6 string pickup most of the time. We might be able to have a 4 string pickup custom made for you too. The routing and electronics work on this guitar ran about $150 as I recall and pickup prices can vary as you might expect.
Steve thanks for the info! I’m going to check out some guitars with a floating pickup this weekend and compare the sounds to get a rough idea. I will give your shop a call next week. thanks again!
This is fantastic, I’ve been wanting to amplify my harmony guitar and haven’t found any sort of online references…until now. Thank you so much!
I found a 50’s archtop don’t know the brand somebody had cut the hole for a neck pick up along with all of the other necessary holes. I bought it for $25. I put a Parsons street Golden age humbucker in it. Should I have put something different in it?
Gene, if you like the sound of that pickup, then you put the right one in! There’s lots of flavors to choose from when it comes to pickups and it can be hard to make a choice when you see how many possiblities there are. We love Lollar and Porter pickups best of all, but your ears know best!
So I have recently picked up one of these harmony hollow body archtops at a goodwill store, and love it. I want to make it more accessable to playing plugged in for gigging reasons, and i was wondering would you suggest putting in a pickup like mentioned? or one of those internal mics that send to a 1/4″ jack? if so whats best for placement of the mic? Pros and cons? feedback? Also whats the proper way to access running the wires internally for a pick up situation ?(hopefully without opening up the body?)and last but not least, suggestion for tunning knob replacements?
Rob,
Your pickup choice would depend on what kind of music you play, where you might perform with it, and what kind of amplification you would use. If you want to play rock, electric jazz, or country music through a guitar amp, then you’ll want to use a regular electric guitar pickup like this one. Lollar makes several varieties that might work well like the Charlie Christian model, the Johnny Smith model, a mini humbucker, or (as in this case) a full-size Imperial humbucker. If you want a more acoustic sound, you would use a pickup that mounts to the top like a K&K Pure Archtop. Hollow body guitars are constructed with lighter woods than solid ones, so they are generally more prone to feedback. But feedback can be controlled by volume, EQ, and by the direction you’re facing. I wouldn’t expect feedback to be such a problem that it wouldn’t be worth the effort.
Hi, I have a harmony archtop just like this and I’d like to install a lollar charlie christian pickup in it. How much would you charge for just the routing? I can do the electronic work but im too paranoid to take a router to the top :P
This looks really cool, how much are your rates, and would you work on a guitar I want, if I have to ship it to you in the mail?
I couldn’t agree with your decision more! I restored an old Harmony Archtop and put a vintage DeArmond pick-up on it and it does everything from totally transparent to gutsy blues and that warm jazz tone that guys like Mickey Baker have! To cool for school.
GOOD AFTERNOON
I FOUND AN HARMONY H1310 I CONVERTED TO NYLON STRING
WHAT KIND OF MICROPHONE CAN I USE…
THANK YOU
Mike, it depends on what kind of sound you’re looking for. If you want to amplify the acoustic response, we would recommend installing use the contact page here for an estimate.
I have a 1960 epiphone ft-30 with the gibson headstock and I want to add a pickup vol/tone and 1/4 jack. Would you advise against this? Thanks
Can you get a floating pickup…that would be suitable for rockabilly
Jon,
The only thing I would advise against is the volume and tone pots. There are a number of pickup options that would be minimally invasive and we’ve become fans of the Taylor/Rapco-Horizon “V-Cable” that has a built-in volume pot. I always feel that in an acoustic guitar, tone control is best adjusted at a mixer or amplifier rather than on the guitar.
Sure, Pubdog! My first thought would be the Lollar Johnnie Smith model. Other options: Stewart MacDonald carries a less expensive Kent Armstrong version that I haven’t heard personally. Seymour Duncan also makes the pickguard-mounted Benedetto pickup.